Top 10 College Football Defenses of All Time
In light of Alabama’s incredibly dominant defensive performance this season that finished with Monday’s 21-0 shutout of LSU in the BCS Championship Game, let’s look at college football’s top defenses of all time based on stats, the unit’s overall legacy and effect on a team’s season.
10. 2008 USC
When you think about USC’s success under Pete Carroll, star quarterbacks and big-play offenses come to mind. But Carroll is a former defensive coordinator and his ‘08 Trojans had a nasty unit. Current NFL linebackers Brian Cushing, Clay Matthews and Rey Maualuga (all pictured) anchored a D that posted three shutouts - and blanked five other opponents after halftime. But who did they play? Well, high-powered Oregon, which averaged almost 42 points per game that season, managed just 10 in a 34-point loss. The Trojans posted a 12-1 record and Rose Bowl win over Penn State. A 27-21 loss to Oregon State is the only thing holding this group back.
9. 1959 Syracuse
The Orange won the 1959 national championship thanks in part to a stout defense that provided some eye-popping statistics. It shut out five teams and allowed just 59 points for the season; that’s like one game for Baylor or Washington this year. The ‘Cuse also had some incredible single-game performances - like the 25 yards of total offense allowed to Boston University. Most people will remember RB Ernie Davis, the Heisman Trophy winner that season, helping ‘Cuse gallop to the national title. But don’t forget the Orange’s big, bad D. We dock them a little bit for lack of competition like Colgate, Boston U. and Holy Cross.
8. 2001 Miami (FL)
When your secondary has Ed Reed and Phillip Buchanon, linebackers include D.J. Williams and Jonathan Vilma, plus a line with NFL first-round picks Jerome McDougle and William Joseph, that’s half of an NFL defense. Williams’ move to his natural position paid off in 2001, when “The U” allowed seven combined points to ranked opponents Washington and Syracuse in November, then held Nebraska and Heisman winner Eric Crouch to just 14 in the Rose Bowl to win a national title. Heck, the ‘Canes’ defense accounted for as many points that night (seven) as the Nebraska offense.
7. 1992 Alabama
Just like this year’s team, the ‘92 Crimson Tide will be remembered for their big-play defense. Defensive back Antonio Langham, whose interception was the inspiration for the ESPN documentary entitled “The Play that Changed College Football,” won the inaugural SEC Championship Game with the aforementioned pick-six. In the ensuing Sugar Bowl, ‘Bama’s George Teague stripped Miami (FL) receiver Lamar Thomas of the ball on what would have been a long TD catch. The Tide’s defense went on to lead them to a 34-13 rout of the high-powered ‘Canes and gave up more points just twice that season.
6. 1985 Oklahoma
Brian “The Boz” Bosworth (pictured) remains one of this defense’s memorable characters, but don’t forget about nose guard Tony Casillas and defensive end Kevin Murphy. All you need to know about the ‘85 Sooners D? They sent a message with a 27-7 throttling of No. 2 Nebraska, which didn’t score on offense and rushed for just 161 yards - less than half the average total from Tom Osborne’s run-heavy attack. The defense then carried the Sooners to a national title with a 25-10 victory over No. 1 Penn State in the Orange Bowl. The defense gave up a total of 28 points in the last seven games, making an early-season 27-14 loss to “The U” an afterthought.
5. 1974 Oklahoma
Most people remember Oklahoma’s Lee Roy Selmon (pictured), the eventual No. 1 overall pick in the 1976 NFL draft, but he was just the tip of OU’s defensive iceberg in 1974. The defense forged three shutouts, two of which came against Big 8 foes Kansas State and Missouri. The Sooners beat the Wildcats and Tigers by a combined score of 100-0. OK, so their offense was pretty good, too. But consider that no opponent scored more than 14 points during an 11-0 season. You can thank three-time All-American linebacker Rod Shoate - the heart and soul of the Sooner defense - for setting the tone.
4. 2011 Alabama
When Alabama CB Dre Kirkpatrick proclaimed on Monday night that Alabama had “the greatest defense in the world,” and “the greatest defense to ever touch the field,” he wasn’t far off. The Tide allowed LSU to cross midfield only once in the national title game and finished the season ranked first in points allowed (8.2 PPG). Only one team scored more than 14 against the Tide all year and that was FCS Georgia Southern, which caught Alabama snoozing between SEC games. We are going to look back on ‘Bama’s unit (Kirkpatrick, LB Courtney Upshaw, LB Don’t’a Hightower, S Mark Barron, etc.) as one full of future NFL stars and the best defense of the modern era.
3. 1947 Penn State
In all honesty, it’s not really fair comparing defenses to the ’47 Nittany Lions unit that was comprised of many ringers in the form 20-something World War II veterans. That would be like Terrence Cody, Marcell Dareus, Rolando McClain and DeMeco Ryans still playing for the Tide. Penn State allowed 40 points total in 10 games and set two NCAA records that are impossible to break: 0.64 yards per carry and 17 rushing yards per game. The 9-0-1 squad finished the season by tying SMU in the Cotton Bowl, 13-13.
2. 1966 Notre Dame
Ah, yes - remember when Notre Dame was great? They were in 1966, when the Irish allowed 38 points all season with the likes of DE Alan Page and DTs Peter Duranko and Kevin Hardy. The schedule was pretty soft but Notre Dame did shut out No. 10 Oklahoma, 38-0, and No. 10 USC, 51-0, and had a total of six shutouts en route to a national title. A future Pro Football Hall of Famer, the 6-foot-5, 230-pound Page was a man amongst boys coming off the edge.
1. 1961 Alabama
As great as the Crimson Tide were this season, they weren’t even the best defense in school history. That honor belongs to the ’61 unit led by LB Lee Roy Jordan that is the equivalent of the 1985 Chicago Bears for college football: This is the unit all great college defenses are compared to. Alabama didn’t allow a single opponent to score more than seven points all season and gave up 25 points total in 11 games, including five consecutive shutouts. Granted, this was a different time in college football before spread offenses and prolific passing games, but the ’61 Alabama defense led by LB Lee Roy Jordan (pictured) and DT Billy Neighbors will never be topped.